Reality Fan Forum - The Amazing Race Spoilers - Big Brother Live Feed Updates - Survivor Spoilers - Reality TV Spoilers - Big Brother Spoilers

Survivor => Survivor Discussion => Topic started by: Bwils927 on April 05, 2013, 06:30:32 PM

Title: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Bwils927 on April 05, 2013, 06:30:32 PM
I don't see something like this on here, unless i didn't look hard enough, anyways, i can't really rank them, but some that i really liked were:

Borneo, Australia, Pearl Islands, All Stars, Vanuatu, Guatemala, Fiji, China, Micronesia, Gabon, HvV, Redemption Is., South Pacific, Philippines.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Glamazon Racer on April 06, 2013, 04:23:45 AM
I have seen most of Borneo, Australia, Guatemala, Cook, Micronesia, Gabon and Samoa onwards.

From those seasons, Micronesia is my clear favourite, followed closely by Gabon, HvV, Samoa, Cook Islands and Guatemala in that order.

I really hate One World. Also hate SoPa. RI was awful except Phillip. Nicaragua was quite boring except Brenda. And Philippines was superb pre-merge, but horrible from like Final Ten onwards.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Air on April 06, 2013, 04:27:26 AM
I've only seen Samoa onwards, and IMO Samoa was OK, I liked but at the same time hated Russelldomination, LOVED HVV, disliked Nicaragua at the time (except for BRENDA <3 ) but then realised that it was better than everything else since except for Phil, hated RI (everyone was too mindless), really disliked SoPa (because a Savaii didn't win and Upolu I really didn't like ) hated OW (just EW) and Phil was <3 until it became quite boring and alliances got Pagonged.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Jobby on April 06, 2013, 12:28:03 PM
Nicaragua, Fiji, Brazil were some of the really suckass seasons. Nicaragua being the WORST.

Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Bwils927 on April 06, 2013, 12:28:44 PM
I hated the Redemption Island twist, but there were some likeable people even though they might not have been good strategizers. Besides Rob, i really liked Andrea, Natalie, Grant, Matt, and all the Zapateras that made the merge. And i really think SoPa is underrated. The Pagonging of Savaii made it seem boring, but i loved rooting against Coach, and i actually didn't mind Brandon, and i really liked Rick, Albert, and Sophie. One World had such good potential with someone funny like Bill, or a strategic mind like Matt, but Colton just ruined this. I loved Kim Sabrina and Chelsea, but i hated the all female domination, since that meant likeable players like Jonas, Leif, and Jay had absolutely no chance after Mike got voted out. And Philippines was so-so, since i really only had Carter, Malcolm, and Denise to root for after the merge.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Bwils927 on April 06, 2013, 12:29:39 PM
Nicaragua, Fiji, Brazil were some of the really suckass seasons. Nicaragua being the WORST.
I struggle to find why there's so much Fiji hate. And which Brazil, Tocantins or Amazon?
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Reilly Queens on April 06, 2013, 12:37:14 PM
stfu oval
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: addie on April 06, 2013, 12:46:06 PM
From what I've seen:

1. China
2. Vanuatu
3. Philippines
4. Gabon
5. Nicaragua
6. Guatemala
7. Tocantins
8. Samoa
9. SoPa
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Jobby on April 06, 2013, 12:48:29 PM
Nicaragua, Fiji, Brazil were some of the really suckass seasons. Nicaragua being the WORST.
I struggle to find why there's so much Fiji hate. And which Brazil, Tocantins or Amazon?

Tocantins.

The only redeeming factor was Earl won for Fiji and aside from Yau-man, he was definitely most deserving. That season had just too many negative vibes as with Nicaragua.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Jobby on April 06, 2013, 12:49:34 PM
I would also rank Philippines as one of the better seasons and helped save Survivor from going down the drains after South Pacific almost ruin the whole show with all the Redemption Island lame twists.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Bwils927 on April 06, 2013, 02:02:42 PM
Nicaragua, Fiji, Brazil were some of the really suckass seasons. Nicaragua being the WORST.
I struggle to find why there's so much Fiji hate. And which Brazil, Tocantins or Amazon?

Tocantins.

The only redeeming factor was Earl won for Fiji and aside from Yau-man, he was definitely most deserving. That season had just too many negative vibes as with Nicaragua.
I agree, the Four Horseman alliance might be the dumbest alliance ever, and Moto domination gave people like Cassandra and Dreamz a free ride. What made me really like it is that the challenges were AWESOME, it was funny to watch the Four Horsemen broken up, there was lots of idol-playing and finding, it may not be in my top 5, but i really enjoyed that season.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Jobby on April 07, 2013, 12:07:32 AM
Sometimes the Survivors/characters define the Season and Fiji just had one hell of a negative/unmemorable/boring and superficial characters. Same with Nicaragua, where the only positive character I could remember was Jane and Fabio (who was retarded) and maybe Brenda (who was voted out early).

Some of the better seasons I watched AFTER Vanuatu (Palau, even with Ulong completely dying, that was a very very interesting season), Guatemala (how Danni won even when she was a minority), Cook Islands (every one complained about racism and look, one of the best seasons ever), Fans VS Favourites (DEFINITELY ONE OF THE BEST), Samoa (I HATED RUSSELL, but the amount of shock factor is too damn high), Heroes VS Villians (WHOOOHOOOO)...

And I liked One World because I like Kim and Christina and they made it all the way till the end. <3 LOL. I'M BIASED.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Bwils927 on April 07, 2013, 12:41:29 PM
Fabio (who was retarded)
And a major stoner  :lol3: But yeah he was awesome.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Reilly Queens on April 07, 2013, 12:50:34 PM
Some of the better seasons I watched AFTER Vanuatu (Palau, even with Ulong completely dying, that was a very very interesting season), Guatemala (how Danni won even when she was a minority), Cook Islands (every one complained about racism and look, one of the best seasons ever), Fans VS Favourites (DEFINITELY ONE OF THE BEST), Samoa (I HATED RUSSELL, but the amount of shock factor is too damn high), Heroes VS Villians (WHOOOHOOOO)...


AGreed <3
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: IvarG on April 07, 2013, 01:28:51 PM
I'm trying to figure out what season to watch. I've seen Heroes vs. Villains, Phillipines, Caramoan and South Pacific. I'm thinking Cook Islands... got any suggestions? I think I can find all of them online.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: addie on April 07, 2013, 01:29:40 PM
China <3
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: coolio on April 07, 2013, 01:40:54 PM
1. Micronesia
2. China
3. Cook Islands
4. Heroes vs. Villains
5. All Stars
6. Borneo
7. Pearl Islands
8. Philippines
9. Tocantins
10. Africa
11. Samoa
12. One World
13. Panama
14. Australia
15. Amazon
16. Vanuatu
17. Palau
18. Gabon
19. Fiji
20. Marquesas
21. Nicaragua
22. South Pacific
23. Guatemala
24. Redemption Island
25. Thailand
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Bwils927 on April 07, 2013, 03:07:16 PM
I'm trying to figure out what season to watch. I've seen Heroes vs. Villains, Phillipines, Caramoan and South Pacific. I'm thinking Cook Islands... got any suggestions? I think I can find all of them online.
Try Guatemala or Cook. They were amazing. Also if you're looking into the early seasons, maybe try Australian Outback or All Stars.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: MrDeerShank on April 07, 2013, 03:16:19 PM
China minus Amanda not winning <3
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Bwils927 on April 07, 2013, 03:28:41 PM
Here's my official ranking:

1. Guatemala
2. Gabon
3. Cook Islands
4. All Stars
5. Pearl Islands
6. Heroes vs Villains
7. Micronesia
8. Fiji
9. Australian Outback
10. Philippines
11. Borneo
12. China
13. Redemption Island
14. South Pacific
15. Vanuatu
16. Palau
17. Samoa
18. Marquesas
19. Africa
20. Tocantins
21. Nicaragua
22. One World
23. Amazon
24. Panama
25. Thailand
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Reilly Queens on April 07, 2013, 03:52:13 PM
Here's my official ranking:

1. Guatemala
2. Gabon
3. Cook Islands
4. All Stars
5. Pearl Islands
6. Heroes vs Villains
7. Micronesia
8. Fiji
9. Australian Outback
10. Philippines
11. Borneo
12. China
13. Redemption Island
14. South Pacific
15. Vanuatu
16. Palau
17. Samoa
18. Marquesas
19. Africa
20. Tocantins
21. Nicaragua
22. One World
23. Amazon
24. Panama
25. Thailand

(http://media.tumblr.com/35a8cf2a8fea5b415b21764dc37fe437/tumblr_inline_mhye0eRF691qz4rgp.gif)

I disagree
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Bwils927 on April 07, 2013, 06:10:15 PM
Many others would as well.  :)

Eliza  :hrt:
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Jobby on April 08, 2013, 08:27:16 AM
Some of the better seasons I watched AFTER Vanuatu (Palau, even with Ulong completely dying, that was a very very interesting season), Guatemala (how Danni won even when she was a minority), Cook Islands (every one complained about racism and look, one of the best seasons ever), Fans VS Favourites (DEFINITELY ONE OF THE BEST), Samoa (I HATED RUSSELL, but the amount of shock factor is too damn high), Heroes VS Villians (WHOOOHOOOO)...


AGreed <3

I liked Samoa cause Natalie won. LOL
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Bwils927 on April 08, 2013, 09:38:27 AM
Same. And Erik Cardona's speech was amazing. I actually liked Mick and Jaison, but they were so undeserving it's not even funny.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: addie on April 08, 2013, 01:42:30 PM
Mick and Jaison were pathetic, sry.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: MrDeerShank on April 08, 2013, 05:01:55 PM
Here's my official ranking:

1. Guatemala
2. Gabon
3. Cook Islands
4. All Stars
5. Pearl Islands
6. Heroes vs Villains
7. Micronesia
8. Fiji
9. Australian Outback
10. Philippines
11. Borneo
12. China
13. Redemption Island
14. South Pacific
15. Vanuatu
16. Palau
17. Samoa
18. Marquesas
19. Africa
20. Tocantins
21. Nicaragua
22. One World
23. Amazon
24. Panama
25. Thailand

(http://media.tumblr.com/35a8cf2a8fea5b415b21764dc37fe437/tumblr_inline_mhye0eRF691qz4rgp.gif)

I disagree
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Bwils927 on April 08, 2013, 06:09:51 PM
Mick and Jaison were pathetic, sry.
I liked them as people, but i do agree that they were pathetic players and also totally underserving.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: jlim201 on May 10, 2013, 04:41:19 PM
1) Micronesia (eliza jury reactions and erik giving away idol.)
2) Palau
3) Philippines (Its just stands out in bad recent seasons )
4)Borneo
5)Australian Outback
6) All-Stars
7)China (A break from the tropical beaches and Todd's strategizing  :yess:
8)Vanuatu
9) Guatemala
10) Caramoan (Malcolm returning, Brenda returning :yess:
11) Cook Islands
12)Fiji
13)Panama
14)Gabon (liked two switches)
15)Nicaragua (BRENDA :yess:)
16)South Pacific (don't love it but don't hate it either)
17)One World (liked one world twist but not the cast "over arrogant troyzan etc.)
18) Pearl Islands (don't like Sandra)
19) Heroes vs Villains (villains I like elim early and heroes pagonged)
20) Amazon
21)Tocantins
22)Africa
23)Marquesas
24)Thailand
25) Redemption Island ("rob zombies" and matt not flipping  :'(
26) Samoa (russell :( :'(

based on earlier posts, I think others will disagree
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Ryan on April 03, 2015, 12:04:23 PM
Might be interesting to see what some folks think on season breakdown, now that we've got more activity boosting the Survivor community - here's my rough season breakdown by tier, can't exactly place them line by line:


Tier 1: Micronesia, Heroes v Villains, Caramoan, Philippines, Thailand, Cook Islands, China, Samoa, San Juan Del Sur, Guatemala

Tier 2: Borneo, Aussie Outback, Panama, Tocantins, Marquesas, Worlds Apart, Nicaragua, Cagayan, Blood vs Water

Tier 3: All-Stars, Palau, Pearl Islands, Africa, Amazon, One World

Tier 4: Vanuatu, Fiji, Gabon, Redemption Island, South Pacific

Tier 1
Guatemala was the first season with an idol and had a colorful cast that I think is under appreciated, some obvious great seasons in that first tier are due to "returnee" status, and I thought some unique folks in Philippines/Cook/China/Samoa were fantastic, Russel owned his season and I don't find him nearly as unlikable. Todd's China dominance and Brian's Thailand game really appealed to me, even if Brian nearly bombed out in his FTC to edge out the horrendous Clay.

Post-merge SJDS was awesome too.

Tier 2
Some early series greats created a lot of foundation for me in watching this show, even though I watched S3-S10 after a lot of newer ones. Tribe dynamics in Tocantins, Panama, and Cagayan were fun to watch and see play out, much like Worlds Apart is currently (and depending on what happens moving forward, World Apart could move up to Tier 1 for me.) The first instance of BvW was a nice twist and Nicaragua has a slew of colorful characters I'd love to see play again, even if people didn't like the season overall.

Tier 3
All-Stars was a bit disappointing for me - really thought they had a lot of floaters come back, even if they were iconic that doesn't mean I wanted to see them play again (Rudy, Tom B...most of the winners even weren't fun a second time around); Palau I was meh on because I thought Steph went deeper after her tribes decimation, but glad she didnt' so Guatemala could happen. The rest are just either seasons where predictable things happened, or I didn't like the characters as much (though granted I didn't appreciate Rob C in Amazon until much later, and was bummed he was an early All-Stars boot.)

Tier 4
Vanuatu, meh, not bad and I like that the ladies took over, but then Chris won and I was like "ugh." Fiji and Gabon had some cool characters (CORRINE!) but overall not fantastic seasons (Big Brother style Fiji and the weird division of tribes in Gabon..)

Redemption Island + SPacific - in theory, cool to have 2 returnees from other seasons and see how that dynamic works out, but Redemption Island as a concept was always SO predictable, rarely did someone "upset" out there and kick out someone super strong. Not to mention I'm not a Boston Rob fan, Philip was disgusting (now I appreciate Ashley from that season SO much more for her fierce play), and Coach was tiring in his third appearance.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: fossil-racer on April 03, 2015, 12:21:17 PM
1 Cagayan
2 Palau
3 Heroes vs Villains
4 Micronesia
5 Philippines
6 Caramoan
7 Samoa
8 Guatemala- 1st season i watched
9 Tocantins
10 South Pacific
11 Exile Island
12 Amazon
13 China
14 Blood vs Water
15 Cook Islands
16 San Juan del Sur
17 One World
18 Redemption Island
19 Pearl Islands
20 Gabon
21Fiji
22 All- Stars
23 Nicaragua
24 Vanautu
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Marionete on April 03, 2015, 02:11:57 PM
I just gotta say Caramoan is one of the worst seasons EVER, along with One World. They shouldn't be rated as high imo. OW was just boring and predictable while Caramoan had the worst possible group of returnees :iok I only liked Brenda, Malcolm, Corinne and Andrea (also Franny, who... didn't really play... again..) and they were all considered FAVOURITES... (:;) The whole Philip stealth r us parody left a horrible stench. Plus all the Dawn meltdowns.... :groan:
Oh, and I hated Cochran, so... yeah...

From recent seasons, Cagayan is definitely the best. :<3
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Bookworm on April 03, 2015, 02:35:39 PM
My personal ranking and organization of tiers.

1. Heroes vs Villains
2. Cagayan
3. Micronesia
4. China
5. Cook Islands
6. Borneo
7. Tocantins
8. Australia
9. Pearl Islands
10. Blood vs Water
11. Philippines
12. San Juan Del Sur
13. Guatemala
14. Samoa
15. Caramoan
16. Palau
17. All Stars
18. Panama
19. Amazon
20. Africa
21. Gabon
22. Thailand
23. One World
24. Nicaragua
25. Vanuatu
26. Marquesas
27. South Pacific
28. Fiji
29. Redemption Island
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: selfeviction on April 04, 2015, 08:46:38 PM
18 Redemption Island
19 Pearl Islands
20 Gabon
21Fiji
22 All- Stars
23 Nicaragua
24 Vanautu
Pearl Islands was AN AMAZING season imo. I can't believe you put RI ahead of it.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: stekay on April 04, 2015, 09:41:47 PM
This Gabon hate is unjust and unlawful
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: gamerfan09 on April 04, 2015, 09:43:08 PM
RI and SoPa are definitely at the bottom of my list.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: selfeviction on April 04, 2015, 11:45:35 PM
^ OMG YES, South Pacific was a horrific season, Savaii getting pagogned and then Ozzy almost winning to make the season a little better but chokes at F4 IC, and a F3 of Sophie,Albert, & Coach? Hated the F3.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: stekay on April 05, 2015, 09:27:16 AM
Ew sevii were gross. Coach should've won
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Marionete on April 05, 2015, 12:36:44 PM
This Gabon hate is unjust and unlawful
Totally! I was a really great season with interesting twists and ann amazing cast! The winenr was great too btw :<3

In SoPa I was rooting for Savaii - Keith, Whitney, Jim, Dawn (before she was a Caramoan freak) - and all of the worst people made it to the top, thank God Sophie won and not someone like Albert or Rick.. And btw I liked Ozzy & Coach on for entertainment (though I'd have rather had just 18 newbies), but didn't liked their gameplay that specific season and didn't want a returnee to win.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Ryan on April 05, 2015, 12:48:16 PM
I actually do like Gabon in some ways, but for me compared to other seasons, the tribe assignments in the beginning we're ridic and made it super unbalanced. Gillian, Susie, Crystal, Randy should not all have been on one original tribe. Granted they didn't know Crystal would suck at every challenge :P

SoPa's Christine/Stacey <3<3 - I loved Dawn that season, and Sophie winning redeemed a lackluster season. I am anti-Coach, though. Also Rick, like easily up there for one of the MOST invisible castaways of all time. Barely any confessionals and somewhat of a Keith in that he had no clue what he was doing.

Redemption concept could have worked out well, just an odd mix cast and HATE Philip.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Marionete on April 05, 2015, 01:00:04 PM
Oh yeah, I forgot my two favourites - Sophie and Christine - were on the outs and were booted pre-merge :( I was hoping for Christine to return, but then Ozzy came.....
Pretty much the same was with RI - Kristina and Francesca were on the outs and they were like my favourite people on Ometepe.... AND I'm a superfan of Russell because he brings so much to the game, but he and the awesome Stephanie + Krista as well got booted pre-merge :gaah: At least one of them might return.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: stekay on April 05, 2015, 01:37:40 PM
I actually do like Gabon in some ways, but for me compared to other seasons, the tribe assignments in the beginning we're ridic and made it super unbalanced. Gillian, Susie, Crystal, Randy should not all have been on one original tribe. Granted they didn't know Crystal would suck at every challenge :P

Unbalanced but they all got to the jury stage :P
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: fossil-racer on April 05, 2015, 01:46:22 PM
I ranked everything based on how good the
logo was
Cast was
Pre-merge was
Post-Merge was
Winner was
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Ryan on April 06, 2015, 11:24:43 AM
I actually do like Gabon in some ways, but for me compared to other seasons, the tribe assignments in the beginning we're ridic and made it super unbalanced. Gillian, Susie, Crystal, Randy should not all have been on one original tribe. Granted they didn't know Crystal would suck at every challenge :P

Unbalanced but they all got to the jury stage :P

Doesn't impact season quality overall for me though, my point was it was extremely boring when Kota won nearly every challenge because they had a much stronger team, even after the swap happened. Granted with the old folks on Espada in Nicaragua the same thing happened, but tribal dynamics were a bit more interesting and I just felt they had some people playing harder out there. Though the double-quit of Naonka and Purple Kelly should be a huge plummet for me since I hate quits with a passion :P

Also random fact about Gabon I just found out - 5 players were age 29 :P
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: stekay on April 06, 2015, 02:04:36 PM
Randy's vote out is one of the best tribal councils ever sorry. Also Sugar's story arc is incredibly glam
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: selfeviction on April 06, 2015, 08:14:28 PM
I loved Gabon, lots of big characters (Sugar, Randy, Corinne, Crystal <3)
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Ryan on April 07, 2015, 09:53:44 AM
Crystal is one of my all-time favs, and I don't hate Sugar as much as others do, maybe I need to move Gabon higher. XD

The rolling giant ball down mountain challenge with Ace/Dan as goalies was fun to watch haha.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Jobby on May 06, 2015, 10:06:35 AM
Jeff hated Gabon but the viewers loved it. Maybe seasons Jeff hates = viewers love and seasons Jeff likes = viewers hate? :funny:
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: gamerfan09 on May 06, 2015, 10:07:37 AM
Jeff hated Gabon but the viewers loved it. Maybe seasons Jeff hates = viewers love and seasons Jeff likes = viewers hate? :funny:

Could be true! As far as I know, he hates San Juan Del Sur, and that season was just as good if not better than Cagayan!
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: David on May 06, 2015, 11:26:38 AM
Jeff hated Gabon but the viewers loved it. Maybe seasons Jeff hates = viewers love and seasons Jeff likes = viewers hate? :funny:

Could be true! As far as I know, he hates San Juan Del Sur, and that season was just as good if not better than Cagayan!

He loved flops apart bye
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: realshowfan on May 06, 2015, 01:07:00 PM
I'm hoping for another culture-themed season like China, Guatemala and Pearl Islands. I think Philippines was the last season of that kind.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Marionete on May 06, 2015, 01:52:37 PM
^ omg yes

Jeff hated Gabon but the viewers loved it. Maybe seasons Jeff hates = viewers love and seasons Jeff likes = viewers hate? :funny:

Could be true! As far as I know, he hates San Juan Del Sur, and that season was just as good if not better than Cagayan!
Not better than Cagayan by no means, but there were definitely characters and post-merge was awesome! Cagayan was amazing throughout and had even more amazing people imo :luvya:
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Ryan on May 06, 2015, 08:32:19 PM
Cagayan was much better than SJDS, but I do still place SJDS outside the bottom 10 seasons - much worse play. Post-merge SJDS had a big handful of power players all vying for control.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: gamerfan09 on May 06, 2015, 08:34:10 PM
Cagayan was much better than SJDS, but I do still place SJDS outside the bottom 10 seasons - much worse play. Post-merge SJDS had a big handful of power players all vying for control.

The F6 was PERFECT though with Jon/Jaclyn, Keith, Natalie, Missy/Baylor <3
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Bookworm on May 06, 2015, 08:56:36 PM
Cagayan was much better than SJDS, but I do still place SJDS outside the bottom 10 seasons - much worse play. Post-merge SJDS had a big handful of power players all vying for control.

The F6 was PERFECT though with Jon/Jaclyn, Keith, Natalie, Missy/Baylor <3
The Cagayan F6 was also great, we had Tony, Kass, Tasha, Trish, and Spencer! The only not-great player was Woo.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: jlim201 on May 08, 2015, 06:51:09 PM
Ranking them into groups- Excellent, Good, Decent, Bad, (and "have not watched")

Excellent:

Amazon
All-Stars
Panama
China
Micronesia
Cagayan

Good

Philippines
One World
BvW 1
Heroes vs Villains
Palau
Guatemala
Australian Outback
Tocantins

Decent

Pearl Islands
Samoa
South Pacific
Cook Islands
Fiji
Nicaragua
San Juan Del Sur

Bad

Redemption Island
Gabon

Have NOT watched

Borneo
Africa
Marquesas
Thailand
Vanuatu
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: naejae91 on May 11, 2015, 10:31:06 PM
deleted
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: selfeviction on May 11, 2015, 11:59:35 PM
Rank from Best to Worst
1. China
2. Heroes vs. Villains
3. Borneo
4. Pearl Islands
5. Cagayan
6. Micronesia
7. Gabon
8. Philippines
9. Australia
10. Tocantins
11. Palau
12. San Juan del Sur
13. Blood vs. Water
14. Amazon
15. Africa
16. One World
17. Nicaragua
18. Worlds Apart (if Mike/Carolyn/Sierra win, S30 goes significantly up for me)
19. Vanuatu
20. Marquesas
21. Fiji
22. Panama
23. All Stars
24. Guatemala
25. Thailand
26. Samoa
27. Cook Islands
28. South Pacific
29. Caramoan
30. Redemption Island
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: gamerfan09 on May 12, 2015, 12:47:46 AM
I actually started watching from China onwards. I haven't seen enough of the rest, but here's my ranking (in no particular order)!

Amazing:
Heroes vs. Villains
Cagayan
China (First season bias)
San Juan Del Sur
Pearl Islands
Australia
Africa
Micronesia
Amazon

Good:
Philippines
Gabon
Cambodia
Blood vs. Water
Tocantins

Alright:
Cook Islands
Nicaragua

Awful:
All Stars
One World
Samoa
South Pacific
Caramoan
Worlds Apart
Redemption Island
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: WinTar on May 16, 2015, 11:50:38 PM
From what I have watched..

Top Tier:
Micronesia
Heroes vs. Villains
Pearl Islands
Cagayan

Great:
China
Amazon
Gabon
Philippines
San Juan del Sur
Guatemala

Good:
Samoa
All-Stars
Palau
Tocantins
Blood vs. Water
Panama

Average:
Worlds Apart
Nicaragua
Caramoan
Cook Islands
South Pacific

Bad:
One World

Real Bad:
Redemption Island
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: fossil-racer on May 21, 2015, 02:09:24 PM
Worlds Apart 13 out of 25
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: naejae91 on May 21, 2015, 11:09:54 PM
Deleted
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Wadsy591 on August 23, 2015, 08:03:43 PM
[This message has been deleted at the request of the original poster]
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: fossil-racer on August 23, 2015, 08:15:43 PM
My personal best to worst rankings:

1. Micronesia: Fans Vs Favourites
2. Cook Islands
3. Heroes Vs Villains
4. Borneo
5. Pearl Islands: Panama
6. All-Stars
7. Philippines
8. Australia
9. Worlds Apart
10. Palau
11. China
12. Caramoan
12. Vanuatu
14. Samoa
15. San Juan Del Sur
16. Blood Vs Water
17. Marquesas
18. Panama
19. Amazon
20. Redemption Island
21. Tocantins
22. Guatamala
23. Africa
24. Gabon
25. Nicaragua
26. South Pacific
27. One World
28. Gabon
29. Fiji
30. Thailand
Where's Cagayan?
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Wadsy591 on August 23, 2015, 08:58:43 PM
[This message has been deleted at the request of the original poster]
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Wadsy591 on October 12, 2015, 07:40:59 PM
[This message has been deleted at the request of the original poster]
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Parovic on December 01, 2015, 12:02:44 AM
Ranking from the Best to Worst


Top 10
1. Heroes vs Villains
2. Cagayan
3. Cambodia
4. Cook Islands
5. Pearl Islands
6. Amazon
7. Micronesia
8. Australian Outback
9. China
10. Blood vs Water

Just OK
11. Worlds Apart
12. San Juan Del Sur
13. Borneo
14. Phillippines
15. Samoa
16. Fiji
17. All-Stars
18. Palau
19. Exile Island
20. Gabon

Not very fond of...
21. Caramoan
22. Guatemala
23. Redemption Island
24. South Pacific
25. Marquesas
26. Tocantins
27. One World
28. Nicaragua
29. Africa
30. Thailand
31. Vanuatu
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: tennis33 on December 01, 2015, 10:22:53 PM
From season 20 - 31.  Best to worst

1. Blood vs Water
2. Cagayan
3. Cambodia
4. Philippines
5. Worlds Apart
6. SJSD
7. HvsV
8. One world
9. South Pacific
10. Nicaragua
11. Fans vs Fav 2
12. Redemption Isaland.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Wadsy591 on December 08, 2015, 09:12:32 PM
I honestly believe that Vanuatu is the most underrated season, there were so many memorable moments and an obvious case of an underdog.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: fossil-racer on December 10, 2015, 07:06:14 PM
1 Cagayan
2 Palau
3 Heroes vs Villians
4 Micronesia
5 Cambodia- so far
6 Phillippines
7 Caramoan
8 Samoa
9 Guatemala
10 Tocantins
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Marionete on December 11, 2015, 11:57:43 AM
CARAMOAN??? ?? ? ??

 :barf :barf
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: gamerfan09 on December 11, 2015, 12:03:40 PM
The placement of Caramoan and Samoa baffles me :lol:
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Bookworm on December 11, 2015, 03:33:52 PM
In what universe is Caramoan better than Tocantins?
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: naejae91 on December 11, 2015, 06:13:39 PM
I honestly believe that Vanuatu is the most underrated season, there were so many memorable moments and an obvious case of an underdog.
This.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: WinTar on December 12, 2015, 09:37:39 AM
I don't get the Samoa hate.
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Reilly Queens on December 12, 2015, 09:42:15 AM
Amazon
Pearl Islands
Micronesia
San Juan Del Sur
Heroes vs Villains
Australian Outback
Philippines
Cagayan
Vanuatu
Marquesas
China
Exile Island
Gabon
Nicaragua
Tocantins
Guatemala
Blood vs Water
All Stars
Africa
Palau
Borneo
Cook Islands
Samoa
Thailand
Worlds Apart
One World
Fiji
South Pacific
Caramoan
Redemption Island


Blue - GOdly tier
Green - Amazing tier
Yellow - Okay tier
Orange - Bad
Red - Horribad
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Marionete on December 12, 2015, 09:43:18 AM
I absolutely loved Samoa and have seen it 2 times, but I may be biased as it was my first fully-seen season.
But there was definitely something REALLY wrong about Samoa - the editing. Many of the people who got far received very little screentime and I felt like I didn't know/remember anything about most of the cast after the season. Russell and Shambo definitely dominated screentime and then Natalie had to be featured as she eventually won. But Brett, Mick, Jaison - they were all in the final and were UTR throughout the entire season :gnome :didimiss:


Reilly, I thought most people (especially on RFF) found SJDS very mediocre. What did you find so amazing about it? ???
The bottom 3 couldn't be more on point tbh <333333
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: WinTar on December 12, 2015, 09:46:08 AM
People on RFF love SJDS...
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: gamerfan09 on December 12, 2015, 09:48:11 AM
SJDS was a top tier season lol, even if I don't go in depth an RFF fave won!  :hearts: :hearts: :hearts:
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Reilly Queens on December 12, 2015, 09:49:13 AM
Because this was the core center of power

(http://wwwimage.cbsstatic.com/thumbnails/photos/w596/asset/10/00/06/11/missy.jpg)

(http://www.truedorktimes.com/s29/images/e10/e10tv63.jpg)
Which is better than the Cagayan/WA/Cambodia power core.

Plus Missy/Baylor dynamic, and Josh/Jeremy being first two merge boots, and even pagonging episodes were enteraining and had drama (reed's boot)
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: naejae91 on December 12, 2015, 11:48:10 AM
(Placement not in order)

Top 10 Region
Borneo
Amazon
Pearl Islands
Vanuatu
Panama: Exile Island
China
Gabon
Nicaragua
Philippines
San Juan Del Sur

Middle 11 Region
Australian Outback
Africa
Marquesas
Palau
Guatemala
Micronesia
Tocantins
Heroes vs Villains
Blood vs Water
Cagayan
Cambodia (New Entry)

Bottom 10 Region
Thailand
All - Stars
Cook Islands
Fiji
Samoa
Redemption Island
South Pacific
One World
Caramoan
Worlds Apart
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Reilly Queens on December 18, 2015, 02:03:22 PM
Amazon
Pearl Islands
Micronesia
San Juan Del Sur
Heroes vs Villains
Australian Outback
Philippines
Cagayan
Vanuatu
Marquesas
China
Exile Island
Gabon
Cambodia
Nicaragua
Tocantins
Guatemala
Blood vs Water
All Stars
Africa
Palau
Borneo
Cook Islands
Samoa
Thailand
Worlds Apart
One World
Fiji
South Pacific
Caramoan
Redemption Island


Blue - GOdly tier
Green - Amazing tier
Yellow - Okay tier
Orange - Bad
Red - Horribad

Updated with Kimbodia, since I've calmed down from Kimmi's boot and grown to love Kimbodia for Kimmi's morsels, Keith, Kelley, Abi-Maria's reign, and Kass, with the added satisfaction of the entitled and obnoxious "Spensha" joining the 0 vote club (lollll)
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: fossil-racer on December 15, 2016, 12:32:55 PM
Top 10
Cagayan
Cambodia
Palau
Heroes VS Villains
Micronesia
Guatemala
Philippines
Samoa
Millennials VS Gen X
Kaoh Rong

Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Jobby on May 10, 2017, 11:01:56 AM
My Top 5:
Cambodia
Heroes VS Villians
Game Changers
Micronesia
Cook Islands

I'm a sucker for returnees seasons...
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: fossil-racer on May 26, 2017, 11:22:42 PM
Game Changers enters in at #6

Top 10
Cagayan
Heroes VS Villains
Palau
Cambodia
Micronesia
Game Changers
Guatemala
Philippines
Kaoh Rong
Millennials VS Gen X
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: Marionete on May 27, 2017, 12:00:50 PM
Game Changers would not make my personal top 10. :/
Title: Re: Rank the Seasons/Favorite and Least Favorite Seasons
Post by: gamerfan09 on May 28, 2017, 09:37:55 AM
Game Changers is awful BUT its premerge until the Sandra boot episode is genuinely better than everything in Cambodia.