Reality Fan Forum - The Amazing Race Spoilers - Big Brother Live Feed Updates - Survivor Spoilers - Reality TV Spoilers - Big Brother Spoilers
Archive => RFF Archived Boards => American Idol => Topic started by: puddin on May 25, 2004, 09:27:08 PM
-
I had to vote for Fantasia tonight .. I still have chills from her singing tonight..she was right on :;>)
-
heck ya, puddin!!!!
fantasia knocked my socks off!!!
-
Yay drumstyx I can't wait for tonight..
-
OMG.....I am sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo upset to hear that you guys voted for Fantasia.
When Diana sang the song written especially for the AI, I got goosebumps. If Fantasia releases that song the way she sang it last night, I dont think I will ever watch another episode of AI. (thats probobly a lie) I just dont understand what everyone sees in Fantasia...I think she sounds like a Duck or Macy Grey...either way I never was a fan of Macy Grey. I dont think Fantasia can sing a slow song and have the same impact on the audience the way that Diana does. WHen she sings a fast song she just yells into the mic and bouces around like a chicken with her head cut off!!
Sorry for venting but I just dont like her so much!
Hopefully I am not alone in my opinion!!!
What does everyone else think?
-
Don't be mad Pittgirl..Diana has a beautiful voice..and I won't be upset if she wins..I just think that Fantasia sings effortlessly, a natural.. thats just my opinion :-*
-
I think there are a lot of people like you puddin! Thats why i worry for Diana. With Fantasia you either love her or hate her but wiht DIana, people like her but they think Fantasia is better! I hope those Diana fans really come through in Snellville! I cant wait until tonight!
-
I had to vote for Diana (as many times as I could get through) rather than Fantasia. Fantasia is a good singer and she has good stage presence, but I keep trying to think of myself actually listening to her on a CD, without the benefit of the emotional performance she always brings forth. I don't think I can stand her voice for extended periods of time. Diana stumbled a little on that last song, but, gee, her nerves must have been in knots. I feel that Diana could be a singer like Barbra Streisand, and when I see Fantasia all I can think of is Whitney Houston. One has a gift and makes it work for her, the other has a gift and has let her life go to hell. I guess that's kind of a strange parallel to draw, but Fantasia is 19 and hasn't exactly demonstrated sound judgement up to this point. American Idol is the best thing to happen to her, career-wise.
-
Wow amikino, I totally agree with what you are saying about listening to Fantasia on a CD - it would annoy me pretty quickly. Who knew that I would ever agree with an evil Surfan? ;) ;) :-*
Honestly this finale of AI for me is the least interesing one they have had yet. Although I am quite anti-Fantasia, I am not completely gung-ho Diana (like I was for Clay last season). I am not too concerned with who wins tonight. It is one of those things that if I were to miss it, I wouldn't really mind too much (not that I am going to - I'm just sayin' 8) ) .
Oh, and please vote for Refaforu a.k.a. the "kewl" tribe.
-
Yes, I am a Diana fan. I think she fits the "pop idol" model more than Fantasia. I think they both are very talented and can sing but I could not listen to Fantasia -- as her voice is very annoying. And everytime everyone else got chills and got emotional when she sang Summertime, I fast forwarded it on my VCR because I couldn't stand it.
-
I just got back from vacation and had to drive through North Carolina.....when we were driving we were fl;ipping through the radio stations and all you heard about was Fabtasia and they played her song soooooo much! I got sick of it pretty quick ALREADY!
-
Hey Pittgirl :D :D we missed you .. :-*!! Glad to have you back ..so where did you go ? What did you do? Wheres my presents? ;D
hugs....puddin
-
I was in South Carolina....................the beautiful beach with beautiful weather! Had a great time at the beach in the day and the bars by night. So sad to be back....i am ready for another vacation and I have only been back for 2 days!
Anything new around here while I was gone....I tried to catch up on all the stuff I missed......hopefully not too much!
Still looking most forward to TAR............it just cant come soon enough!
-
I'm glad to hear that you had a great time Pittgirl :-*..Check out the amazing race topic..theirs a Allison chat and she confirmed what you already told us 8)...Ally and Donny are not dating any more.. ;)..its really cool to have someone that knows Donny posting on this board !!Thanks Pittgirl..your the best O0 !!
-
thanks puddin.....that was the first place I went too! What a great interview that was. I will post anything else I have in the right board! LOL ;D
-
Sorry it's off the topic, but how do you get those pictures underneath your name?