To each their own!!
My fav hotties are
Season One: AJ Gil, Jim Verraros and Mark Scott(didn't make top 10 but he was dreamy!!)
Season Two: None to report
Season Three: Jon Peter Lewis, Eric Yoder, John Preator and Matthew Metzger (didn't make it either...)
Season Four: Mario Vasquez(again didn't make it)
Season Five: Well Ace is the cutest otherwise non for me!!
Out of all listed above....Mark Scott he can serenade me ANYTIME!!!
For Canadian Idol
Season One: Tyler Hamilton
Season Two: Jacob Hoggard
Season Three: Rex Goudie, Stéphane Aubin, Vince Benenati, Matt Kennedy, Barrett Peitsch
Season Four: Greg Neufeld and Rob James <-- from mcmaster and james