10: Paul McDonald
. He sang "Maggie Mae" and I thought his voice was a little raspy. Steven said: "See that Paul? It's all about the jacket! (LOL)
You have character in the voice, love the character. JLo commented about his smile, "The way you move, all in black but the smile lights up the whole place. Good performance! Randy compared him to Rod Stewart, so unique, quirky and different. He said he was happy that Idol can embrace someone so different. 11: Jacob Lusk
I love this guy, he's unique and a powerful singer, he sang "A House Is Not A Home". Steven Tyler said it was divine intervention that brought him here and he was honored to be in his presence. JLo compared him to Luther Vandross. "he's gone but now we have you." Randy concurred saying, "Luther would be so proud of you, we're lucky to have you here, so proud of you."12: Casey Abrams
LOVED IT! He sang "I Put A Spell On You" and got a standing O from the audience. Steven said he starts out good in his mind, good out of your mind good. Good as it gets Crazy good! JLo said he was sexy. "Sexy Casey! You redefined the whole thing, you took it and ate it all up." Randy said he transformed into the song, so different, so unique.