I had to vote for Diana (as many times as I could get through) rather than Fantasia. Fantasia is a good singer and she has good stage presence, but I keep trying to think of myself actually listening to her on a CD, without the benefit of the emotional performance she always brings forth. I don't think I can stand her voice for extended periods of time. Diana stumbled a little on that last song, but, gee, her nerves must have been in knots. I feel that Diana could be a singer like Barbra Streisand, and when I see Fantasia all I can think of is Whitney Houston. One has a gift and makes it work for her, the other has a gift and has let her life go to hell. I guess that's kind of a strange parallel to draw, but Fantasia is 19 and hasn't exactly demonstrated sound judgement up to this point. American Idol is the best thing to happen to her, career-wise.